My first sig, rates please

[conman1000]

http://img104.imageshack.us/img104/2726/sowt25sigev7.png (http://imageshack.us)

Well, I know it isn't great, but I wanted the rates to have something to build upon.

[Samus-Fan]

I like The Planet.

The sparks are ok, but they look repetitive. Maybe mix up the order, the glow, and the color.
There is a little too much black space on the sides.

Over all, I would give it a total of 7/10

[Riku-Nara]

6/10
Since it's your first time, custom brushes are a must in sigs.
And try not to keep the select line in the sig.
And throw some variety in there too, like samus fan said, but try to stick to a stable color pattern..

[rukisuto]

The sig looks good.
But looks more 'planned out' than 'creative' IMO.
Riku and Samus gave some good advice, I'd go with that.

You're off to a good start :]

6/10

[LiNuX]

gj there :D first sig was good - mine was total crap and i still have it lol, won't show it to you though

give it a 6/10 as well - the yellow stuff doesn't go but planet is good :D

[Kain [IRL]]

I like it, alot better than any of the stuff ive ever come out with :)

[Iceskater101]

good try I love the planet but I think to fill up the space you could have put lettering. trust me my first sig was the worst your's is pretty good. 7/10

[YuriPrime]

Yeah it looks too much like a picture and not enough like a design. Good effort though, especially for a first sig.

[Kiss]

okay for a first, i'll tell ya my first wasn't so hot either, i might be able to dig it up :[

Try more detail next time. Add a C4D, get some brushes, do some blur. overall 4/10

[KittyCat72]

It's interesting... pretty good for a first. I'm not that great myself so I can't really give you any tips but everyone else sounds like they know what they're talking about. :-P You should listen to them.:D