Rate The Sig for

[Cream Suede]

http://img396.imageshack.us/img396/9063/forumsigfinalf2h2psdpz8.jpg (http://imageshack.us)



Constructive critisism please.

[Jaykub]

6.5 of 10. Clean but not to much effects

[Samus-Fan]

Well, the effects aren't that great. In fact, I dunno if I see any.
I see 2 renders, which don't go together at all.
There is a green fractal background that doesn't match both renders, only one.
The font doesn't really fit, but that is pretty easy to repair.
Overall, it isn't amazing, its alright. Another render would just fill it up and make it seem over-filled.
5/10

[Joshuah]

5/10, not the best renders to combine, like Halo and Fable, does not go together ^_^ and try blend it into the background (:

[KittyCat72]

Not that bad... but 5/10. Don't think the colors go with the renders well.

[LiNuX]

5/10 from me as well

1. master chief's purple doesn't go at all

2. the other render would have done much better by itself

3. if you made the background the color of some part of the second render instead of that green, it would have looked a bit more blended in and looked better as a sig

everything anyone said or will say are opinions so don't take negative criticisms too strongly :) you did good, just need a bit more work - I'm sure all graphics people were in your shoes at one point or another in their career

[Cream Suede]

Thank you :) . but yes i realize it is very simple.

[LiNuX]

Thank you :) . but yes i realize it is very simple.

sometimes simple is best :) some of my best sigs are simple ones, usually the ones that took me less than 15 minutes to make lol...the ones i spend an hour on usually suck cuz i try too hard

but you did good - at least you have the basic idea of the whole sig making and look process